| 2025 | The Christmas Campaign | Hank |
| 2025 | The Salem Chronicles | The Villager |
| 2025 | The Wrong Marriage | Louie |
| 2024 | The Merry Gentlemen | Mike |
| 2024 | A Killer in the House | Dr. Roberts/Parole Officer |
| 2024 | Million Dollar Lethal Listing | Custodian 1 |
| 2024 | The Night They Came Home | Judge Parker |
| 2023 | Outlaw Johnny Black | Goat Farmer |
| 2023 | Bikini Bowl-O-Rama | Grabowski (archive footage) |
| 2023 | Stray Cat | Mike (archive footage) |
| 2023 | Murderbot | Diner Owner |
| 2023 | Hypnotique | Danvers (archive footage) |
| 2022 | Murder, Anyone? | David |
| 2022 | Piranha Women | Detective Rogers |
| 2022 | Attack of the 50 Foot Camgirl | Bartender |
| 2022 | The Wrong High School Sweetheart | Bartender |
| 2022 | The Wrong Blind Date | Drunkard (as Mike Gaglio) |
| 2022 | Amityville Uprising | The Bartender |
| 2021 | The Amityville Moon | Bartender |
| 2021 | The Deceased Won't Desist! | First Producer |
| 2021 | The Wrong Prince Charming | Bartender |
| 2021 | The Wrong Mr. Right | Bill |
| 2020 | The Amityville Harvest | Bartender |
| 2019 | 3 Bears Christmas | Phinnias |
| 2019 | The Wrong Cheerleader | Tony |
| 2019 | The Wrong Stepmother | Bar Patron |
| 2018 | Slay Belles | Sheriff |
| 2017 | Dead Man Rising | Mike |
| 2017 | A Doggone Hollywood | Checkers Man (as Mike Gaglio) |
| 2016 | A Christmas in Vermont | Jim |
| 2016 | Escape from Pleasure Planet | General Randall |
| 2016 | Dances with Werewolves | John in Bar |
| 2016 | The Love Machine | Danvers |
| 2016 | Deadly Pickup | Sheriff Bates |
| 2016 | Attack of the Killer Donuts | Mr. Richards |
| 2015 | The Flight Before Christmas | Charity Santa |
| 2015 | Kidnapped: The Hannah Anderson Story | Reporter - Jackson |
| 2015 | Lust in Space | Johnson |
| 2015 | College Coeds vs. Zombie Housewives | Steve |
| 2014 | A Perfect Christmas List | Santa |
| 2014 | Atomic Hotel Erotica | Grismer |
| 2014 | The Great Bikini Bowling Bash | Grabowski |
| 2013 | All I Want for Christmas | Sidewalk Santa |
| 2013 | Social Nightmare | Herbert |
| 2013 | The Big Bust Theory | Carmichael |
| 2012 | Bikini Spring Break | Jones |
| 2012 | Baby Dolls Behind Bars | Hartford |
| 2012 | Busty Housewives of Beverly Hills | Griswald |
| 2012 | Dirty Blondes from Beyond | Mark |
| 2012 | The Teenie Weenie Bikini Squad | Benny |
| 2012 | Celebrity Sex Tape | Butler |
| 2012 | Love in the Cards | |
| 2012 | Lizard Man | Bill Buxley |
| 2011 | Sexual Witchcraft | Mr. Turnbull |
| 2011 | The Bunker | SGT Ben Peterson |
| 2011 | 200 MPH | Dr. Steven |
| 2011 | Bikini Time Machine | Prof. Wells (as Mike Gaglio) |
| 2010 | Mega Shark vs. Crocosaurus | Captain Smalls |
| 2010 | 2010: Moby Dick | Millard 'Duck' Davis |
| 2010 | Milf | Amir |
| 2010 | 8213: Gacy House | Professor Roger Franklin |
| 2010 | Titanic II | Chief Engineer Daniels |
| 2010 | American Bandits: Frank and Jesse James | Otis |
| 2010 | Megaconda | Hoke (as Mike Gaglio) |
| 2008 | Tarzeena: Jiggle in the Jungle | Dr. Mortimer (as Mike Gaglio) |
| 2008 | Death's Door | Adam |
| 2007 | Super Ninja Doll | Talbot (as Mike Gaglio) |
| 2004 | The Halfway House | Inspector Hinds |
| 2003 | Dismembered | Clancey |
| 2000 | Romeo and Juliet | Balthasar |
| 1994 | Manosaurus | Deputy Miller |
| 1993 | GetEven | Bar Patron |
| 1993 | Sandman | T-Bird Owner |
| 1990 | Space Chase | Captain Dern |
